Hysteria over PISA misses the point
Blog by Valerie Strauss/Washington Post
Finland is so over. Now it’s all about Shanghai. The 2009 results released today from the Program for International Student Assessment, known as PISA, caused consternation in the United States today when American students racked up generally average scores in reading, science and math. Where they’ve been for years. Today’s big news: Students from Shanghai, participating for the first time in the program, came out on top in all three areas out of about 65 countries and other education systems. Here come the Chinese, or, rather, the Shanghainese. You’d think it would be the Finns who would be beside themselves: They lost their top literacy ranking to South Korea; the United States was 17th. In math, Sinagpore was second in math; the United States, 31st. In science, Finland, was in second place; the United States, 23rd. Reaction here was swift, sharp and sometimes hysterical. Education Secretary Arne Duncan: “For me, it’s a massive wake-up call.” (more…)