Personal tools

Skip to content. | Skip to navigation

Sections
You are here: Home Newsroom Education News Roundup Archive 2010 October 2010 New York City plan to grade teachers with 'value-added' data is destructive

New York City plan to grade teachers with 'value-added' data is destructive

  • 10-25-2010
  • Bookmark and Share

Opinion by Diane Ravitch/Queens Teacher

Diane Ravitch is author of "The Death and Life of the Great American School System: How Testing and Choice Are Undermining Education."

The New York City Department of Education is rating every teacher in grades four through eight based on their students' reading and math performance gains. Claiming it has no choice under Freedom of Information Laws, it now wants to release the ratings - with the teachers' names attached - to the press. A court will decide the question next month. On the surface, this may sound like a good idea. If students make great gains on tests between one year and the next, doesn't that prove that their teacher is effective? If their scores stagnate or decline, isn't it the teachers' fault? Unfortunately, these assumptions are wrong. Many studies have been carried out to see if "value-added" methodology identifies effective teachers. Based on my close reading, nearly all concur that the methodology is both inaccurate and unstable. (more…)



Document Actions
Connect with IDEA
Subscribe to the news roundup

 

facebook-portlet

 

twitter-portlet

 

rss-portlet